Wednesday, February 6, 2013

"What's the difference between QTalk and Rosetta Stone?"

How many times have you seen the Rosetta Stone ad while browsing the web? The marketing campaign is truly ubiquitous. And in fact, many school principals and administrators are asking us, "What's the difference between QTalk and Rosetta Stone?"
Well, there are many differences, and the big one is that Maurice Hazan's QTalk products and subscriptions are a set of flexible tools for learning language with a teacher, a real, live teacher, whether that teacher is in a traditional classroom, an online Skype classroom, a one-on-one tutoring session, a parent or relative teaching a child, or just a friend who has agreed to help you practice your conversation skills. QTalk's Maurice Hazan states in no uncertain terms, "You learn a language by speaking with another person." Yes, when you are reading, you can expand your vocabulary, but to truly activate and think in the language and be fluent, you must speak with a live person, on a regular basis, and not just repeating a few parrotted phrases but really dig in and express yourself, understand the other person, ask questions, tell stories, and do the things we do with language to build and strengthen our social connections with other people.

When we read a recent review of Rosetta Stone by another language instruction technology company, we found ourselves nodding in agreement, and glad someone is taking the time to describe what you really get with Rosetta Stone, and why it's not the best method to learn a language, especially for children.

Read the Language101 creator's critical Rosetta Stone reviews.Then take a look at the QTalk method and decide for yourself whether you agree with the reviewer. By the way, the Language101 materials look very interesting. QTalk until now has not focused on adult self-study materials, although many adult language learners have found QTalk Online Games helpful as a supplement to what they are doing in their language classes or in lessons with tutors.

UPDATE May 2014: Maurice wanted us to update this post because at the time it was written in Feb 2013, he was not offering a self-study option for students. Now with the advances in tablet and smartphone technology, including the tools for speech recognition, Maurice is determined to bring his teaching method to millions of language learners worldwide, not only in the eleven languages offered at Maurice's Tribeca Language center in New York City's Lower Manhattan, but also in the less commonly taught languages in every part of the world. Maurice also wants to emphasize that his approach is far more effective and much better than Rosetta Stone.

Here is the link to Maurice Hazan's Kickstarter project, and he asks you to pledge, even if only one dollar or seven dollars, but there are some really cool rewards for every level of pledge:
www.kickstarter.com/projects/mauricehazan/visually-speaking-the-science-of-language-acquisit 

You can follow the developments at www.MauriceHazan.com.

No comments:

Post a Comment